A recent BBC news report (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c2dly5ldrxjo) on the NHS placed a spot light on the challenges of integrating Physician Associates (PAs) and Anaesthesia Associates (AAs). When you look at this alongside other widely publicised issues across the public sector including the Post Office Horizon scandal, they all reveal fundamental missteps across the transformation lifecycle. Even at a distance you can see clear signs of poor stakeholder engagement, cultural misalignment, and inadequate accountability.
What lessons can be learned from transformations in the private sector and what can be adapted to meet the distinct needs of these public-sector organisations.
1. Stakeholder-Centric Design
Industry Insights:
My experience is that successful transformations has co-creation at its core. For instance, large-scale transformation in industries such as automotive and telecommunications demonstrate that early engagement with stakeholders, whether employees, regulators, government, or customers, ensures alignment and ownership of changes.
Application to NHS and Post Office:
NHS: Collaborating with doctors, nurses, and patients to co-design PA/AA roles ensures the changes meet the needs of all stakeholders. Structured focus groups and iterative pilots can mitigate resistance.
Post Office: Designing a complex IT system like Horizon benefit from participatory workshops, capturing user feedback from early-stage pilots, reducing deployment risks.
Stakeholder co-creation isn’t just a principle; it’s a process. Tools like stakeholder mapping, focus groups, and user acceptance testing ensure that all voices are heard, especially those directly impacted by the change. Engage stakeholders early and continuously to build trust, align goals, and foster shared ownership of the change.
2. Clarity and Transparency
Industry Insights:
Global mergers and operational integrations in sectors like aerospace and industrial software have shown that clear delineation of roles and responsibilities avoids confusion and builds trust. Transparency, particularly in post-merger integrations, is critical for success.
Application to NHS and Post Office:
NHS: Clearly defining PA/AA responsibilities and communicating these roles to the public can enhance trust and reduce misconceptions.
Post Office: Establishing transparent accountability frameworks can prevent blame culture, ensuring fairness and trust throughout the organisation.
Accountability frameworks must ensure transparency, particularly in high-stakes public-sector changes. Clarity in roles, responsibilities, and reporting mechanisms prevents confusion, mistrust, and systemic blame.
3. Data-Driven Change Management
Industry Insights:
Data analytics, widely used in e-commerce and technology industries, provide actionable insights that drive iterative improvements. Companies leverage predictive analytics to identify issues in real time, ensuring rapid response.
Application to NHS and Post Office:
NHS: Use patient safety and performance data to monitor PA/AA integration, addressing misinformation with evidence-based insights.
Post Office: Implementing anomaly detection tools during IT rollouts would allow real-time identification and resolution of inconsistencies.
Public bodies can adopt private-sector tools like predictive analytics and AI for real-time monitoring and feedback. Transparency in data use builds credibility and trust. Leverage data not only to track progress but also to foster trust drive create back loops and enable real time improvements.
4. Cultural Alignment
Industry Insights:
Large-scale organisational transformations in sectors like telecommunications and energy have shown that addressing cultural resistance is critical. Cross-functional training and leadership alignment are key to building trust and fostering collaboration.
Application to NHS and Post Office:
NHS: Cross-disciplinary mentorship and training programs can build trust between PAs, AAs, and established medical professionals, fostering collaboration.
Post Office: Developing a culture of openness, where employees feel safe raising concerns, is essential for successful system adoption.
Cultural transformation is not a policy decision, its a journey of continuous improvement driven from the top down that is highly sensitive to the the actions behaviours and actions of those leading the organisation. Those leading the organisation must be a model of openness, they need to visibly act in complete alignment to culture principles they want their organisation to embrace.
Respect, collaboration and being seen to have listened is not enough alone, you need to be seen to have listened and be seen to have taken the required action to build trust and underpin any transformation efforts, cultural alignment is as critical enabler in achieving this.
5. Phased Implementation and Pilot Programs
Industry Insights:
Phased rollouts are a cornerstone of risk mitigation in industries like technology and industrial manufacturing. By testing new processes or systems in controlled environments, organisations refine strategies before full-scale deployment.
Application to NHS and Post Office:
NHS: Piloting PA/AA roles in diverse settings allows adjustments based on real-world feedback before broader adoption.
Post Office: Phased rollouts of complex IT systems in varied operational contexts can identify and address potential flaws.
Phased implementation ensures lessons are learned in a controlled environment. Pilot programs should include diverse testing conditions to reflect organisational complexities. Pilot programs and phased rollouts reduce risks, build confidence, and enable iterative improvement.
6. Proactive Conflict Resolution and Leadership Accountability
Industry Insights:
Establishing transformation offices to mediate conflicts and maintain leadership accountability has been effective in industries like private equity-backed enterprises and global manufacturing. Centralised governance aligns operational changes with strategic goals.
Application to NHS and Post Office:
NHS: A dedicated transformation office can mediate disputes between professional groups while ensuring leadership accountability.
Post Office: Independent oversight mechanisms, such as ombudsman systems, can resolve conflicts impartially and maintain focus on systemic improvements.
Centralised governance bodies need clear mandates, diverse representation, and authority to act. Mediation training for leaders can further mitigate conflicts before they escalate. Centralised oversight and proactive conflict resolution keep transformation efforts aligned and prevent disputes from derailing progress.
Reframing the Transformation Approach
Transformation cannot be imposed, co-design with stakeholders ensures alignment and trust. For the NHS, this means co-creating PA/AA roles with all parties. For the Post Office, it would mean designing Horizon with sub-postmasters’ input.
From Imposition to Collaboration: Engage stakeholders early in the process to ensure alignment and trust.
From Blame Culture to Learning Culture: Blame stifles innovation. The NHS and Post Office must adopt learning cultures like aviation and tech, treating mistakes as opportunities for systemic improvement.
From Rushed Deployment to Phased Evolution: Incremental, data-driven change minimises risk. Both organisations must embrace phased implementation, refining approaches through pilot programs before scaling.
From Resistance to Alignment: Cultural resistance derails even the best initiatives. Address it through open communication, shared goals, and continuous engagement.
The NHS and Post Office challenges are not unique, they reflect common transformation pitfalls. Adapting lessons from commerce and industry, these organisations can reframe their approaches to prioritise collaboration, clarity, and cultural alignment. By leveraging tools like pilot programs, transparent accountability frameworks, and proactive governance, the NHS and Post Office can transform past failures into valuable lessons, achieving sustainable and impactful change.
The path forward is clear: trust-building, shared ownership, and incremental progress. Will these institutions take the steps necessary to ensure future success, or will they remain bound by the inertia of past failures?
How Are You Fostering Coalitions to Drive Transformation? Let’s Connect!
As Casey Stengel once said: “The secret of managing is to keep the guys who hate you away from the guys who are undecided.”
Building coalitions isn’t always smooth sailing, but with the right strategies, it can unlock unmatched potential.
Transformational success is rarely about technology or processes alone—it’s about aligning culture, leadership, and operational goals to drive meaningful change.
Let’s take your transformation efforts to the next level, reach out directly at shaun.taylor@rckpm.es for a more in-depth conversation.
About Shaun Taylor
Shaun is a seasoned C-level transformation executive with a proven track record in strategic growth, operational optimisation, and value creation, he specialises in helping c-suite leaders navigate complex transitions. His expertise lies in large-scale and private equity-backed businesses, where he has secured complex transformation and operational successes that have deliver measurable outcomes.
Through the RCK Programme Methods, he brings a structured approach blending agile principles with deep operational insight to align technology, operations, and strategy to achieve sustainable success. Whether it’s Cost Transformation, Value Creation, Enabling ERP-enabled change or building coalitions that foster cultural alignment, Shaun and the RCK team ensure your transformation efforts are not just implemented but delivery the results you have committed.
Comments